California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Final Environmental Impact Report Appeal

Any person, entity, or agent thereof, that submitted comments to the Planning Commission or the Environmental Review Officer on a draft EIR, either in writing during the public review period or orally or in writing at a public hearing on the EIR, may appeal the Planning Commission’s certification of the FEIR.
Administrative Code, Section 31.16(c)(1)

Letter of appeal signed by the appellant or the appellant’s agent shall be filed no later than 30 days after the Planning Commission’s certification of the FEIR.
Administrative Code, Section 31.16(c)(2)

NOTE: If the 30th day falls on a Saturday, Sunday or holiday the appeal may be filed before 5:00 p.m. on the next business day.

The following shall be filed with the Clerk of the Board of Supervisors:

(1 original and 2 hard-copies)

1. Letter of appeal stating the specific grounds for the appeal and any other written materials in support of the appeal;
   
   i. The letter should confirm that the appellant submitted comments to the Planning Commission or the Environmental Review Officer during the EIR comment period either in writing during the public review period, or orally or in writing at a public hearing on the EIR; and
   
   ii. Appellant shall also submit the appeal materials to the Environmental Review Officer at the same time as submittal to the Clerk of the Board;
2. A copy of the Planning Commission’s decision; and
3. $787 Appeal Fee, payable to the San Francisco Planning Department.* Administrative Code, Sections 31.16(b)(1)

NOTE 1: The Clerk of the Board may reject an appeal if appellant fails to comply with Administrative Code, Section 301.16(b)(1).

NOTE 2: Submission of support documentation may be done by electronic means. Any materials will become public records, therefore, if any private information is included, Appellant is responsible for redacting such information prior to submission.

Refund information:
Administrative Code, Section 31.22

* Appeal Fee is subject to annual Consumer Price Index adjustment, as determined by the Controller.

Contact the Clerk's Office at (415) 554-5184 or board.of.supervisors@sfgov.org to confirm current Appeal Fee.

Clerk of the Board of Supervisors
1 Dr. Carlton B. Goodlett Place, Room 244
San Francisco, CA 94102

Upon filing, the Clerk will accept the appeal conditioned on:

1. The Planning Department determining that the appeal has been filed in a timely manner, and 2) The Clerk determining that the appeal otherwise complies with the submittal requirements.
2. The Clerk will mail notice to the appellant(s) of the acceptance or rejection of the appeal within seven working days of the filing of the appeal.
   Administrative Code, Section 31.16(b)(1)

The Clerk will schedule an appeal hearing at a regular meeting of the full Board of Supervisors no less than 21 and no more than 45 days following expiration of the appeal period.
Administrative Code, Section 31.16(b)(4)

The Clerk will inform the appellant of the hearing date and time after the closure of appeal filing period.

The Clerk will send notices to the appellant(s) and all organizations and individuals who previously have requested such notice in writing no less than 14 days prior to the date the appeal is scheduled to be heard by the Board.

The appellant shall provide the names and addresses in label format of interested parties that it wishes the Clerk to notify.
Administrative Code, Section 31.16(b)(4)

NOTE: The Planning Department shall provide to the Clerk the list of individuals and organizations that have commented on the decision or determination in a timely manner, and individuals who requested notice of an appeal, no less than 20 days prior to the scheduled hearing.

The public, appellant, and the project sponsor may submit written materials to the Clerk of the Board no later than noon, 11 days prior to the hearing.

Additional documentation the appellant would like the Board members to consider after the 11-day deadline must be delivered to the Clerk. Materials submitted after the 11-day deadline will be marked as “received after the 11-day deadline” and placed in the Board file.
Administrative Code, Section 31.16(b)(5)

The Board by a majority vote of all of its members may affirm or reverse the certification of the FEIR by the Planning Commission.

The Board will act on the appeal within 30 days of the date scheduled or within 40 days if the Board does not hold at least three regular Board meetings within 30 days of the scheduled hearing.

If the full Board is not present, the Board may postpone a decision until the full Board is present. The Board may not postpone the decision on the appeal for more than 90 days following expiration of the time for appeal.
Administrative Code, Section 31.16(b)(7) and (8)

Only the Board of Supervisors (not the Clerk of the Board) can continue the appeal hearing or grant a written request for continuance.

A written request must be submitted by an appellant and the project sponsor, in advance, for the Board’s consideration.
Administrative Code, Section 31.16(b)(7)